1664: The Founding of Elizabethtown, New Jersey’s First City
Introduction: A New Chapter in Colonial America
In 1664, a pivotal chapter in Elizabeth’s colonial history began with a land purchase from local Indigenous people. By 1665, settlers had established homes and a growing village known as Elizabethtown. These beginnings laid the groundwork for commerce, governance, and cultural transformation. City of Elizabeth: Early History
When was Elizabeth, New Jersey founded—1664 or 1665?
The dates refer to different milestones: the land purchase in 1664, an established village by 1665, and incorporation as the City of Elizabeth in 1855. Elizabeth’s municipal history distinguishes all three. Founding of Elizabeth
Founding Dates at a Glance
| Date | Milestone | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 1664 | Land purchase associated with the community’s beginnings. | City history |
| By 1665 | Homes and a village established at Elizabethtown. | City history |
| 1855 | Elizabeth incorporated as a city. | City history |
The Dutch Influence & English Takeover
Before English colonial rule, the region was part of New Netherland. Dutch commerce and settlement formed part of the colonial landscape that English authorities sought to control. In 1664, Peter Stuyvesant surrendered New Netherland to English forces without a battle. National Park Service: The Rise and Fall of New Netherland
The legal grants and military takeover were distinct events. On June 24, 1664, the Duke of York conveyed the territory between the Hudson and Delaware rivers to Lord John Berkeley and Sir George Carteret. The English takeover followed later that year. The territory granted to Berkeley and Carteret became known as New Jersey. New Jersey State Archives: June 1664 release
The Founding of Elizabethtown
Elizabeth’s tourism history dates the land purchase to October 28, 1664, naming John Bailey, Daniel Denton, and Luke Watson as purchasers. The tract lay between the Raritan and Passaic rivers and extended west from Newark Bay. Its history also records a December conveyance to John Baker, John Ogden, John Bailey, and Luke Watson, followed by the construction of houses before April 1665. Visit Elizabeth: Area Information
Philip Carteret arrived as governor in August 1665. Elizabethtown became the seat of government, named in honor of Lady Elizabeth Carteret. His arrival belongs to the settlement’s 1665 development, rather than the 1664 purchase. New Jersey State Archives chronology, p. 5 of PDF
The waterways described in the purchase account help place Elizabethtown within its wider colonial setting. The community developed into New Jersey’s first capital, and the colony’s first legislature met there in 1668. City of Elizabeth: Early History
From Elizabethtown to the City of Elizabeth
Elizabeth’s colonial beginnings should not be confused with its later municipal incorporation. In 1855, it was incorporated as a city following legislative approval and a public vote. The 1664, 1665, and 1855 dates therefore describe stages in the community’s history, rather than interchangeable founding dates. City of Elizabeth: Growth and Incorporation
Explore more stories in Founding & Colonial Era and 1668: New Jersey’s First General Assembly Meets in Elizabethtown.
Sources
Experience This History in Person
